Proof of delivery and chargebacks: what evidence actually holds

In an item not received chargeback, the evidence that wins is delivery confirmation showing the delivery date and the full address matching the order. A tracking page with a city name is not enough, and a bare delivered scan does not say who received the package. A signature, or a photo that can be tied to the order, the place and the time, is what closes the gap.

Two camps meet in this dispute, and both have a real grievance. The merchant, courier or field service company already delivered the goods or did the job, and now has to prove it months later to a bank that only reads documents. The customer stares at a tracking page that says delivered next to an empty doorstep, and the card dispute is the tool their bank gave them. This guide covers what the card networks actually accept as proof, what each side should do, and how to produce delivery evidence nobody has to argue about.

Rules checked on November 11, 2026 against Visa's public dispute guidance and current merchant documentation. The detailed rulebooks go through your acquirer or payment provider, so confirm specifics with them.

What counts as proof of delivery in a chargeback

When a cardholder files an item not received dispute (Visa calls it dispute condition 13.1), the bank asks the merchant for evidence the goods reached the agreed destination. What carries weight is specific: the delivery date, and the full delivery address matching the order, not just a city and postal code. Merchant documentation is blunt about the weak spots: a tracking link showing a partial address is not accepted, and a delivered status alone does not establish who received the package. A signature from the cardholder or an authorized person, or delivery evidence tied clearly to the address and the time, is what completes the file. Visa's own public guidance adds a habit worth copying: request acknowledgement from the customer once the goods are delivered or the service is completed.

One correction to a widespread belief: Visa Compelling Evidence 3.0 does not cover item not received disputes. CE 3.0 applies to card absent fraud disputes (condition 10.4) and works through prior undisputed transactions from the same cardholder. For a not received case, your defense is the delivery file itself, which is why the quality of what you capture at the doorstep decides the outcome months before any dispute exists.

For merchants, couriers and field teams: building the file before the dispute

The chargeback is lost or won at delivery time, not at response time. If your courier's photo shows a package on an anonymous doormat, cropped so no door number is visible, with a date that lives only in the courier's own system, the bank sees exactly what the cardholder's lawyer would point out: a photo that could be any doorstep, any day. The same logic applies to field service: an after photo of a repaired unit proves little if nothing fixes where and when it was taken.

Build the file so each delivery or job produces one record with four properties: the goods or the completed work visible, the place identifiable (door number, meter serial, site reference in frame), a date that comes from a system the driver cannot edit, and a format you can hand to the bank as is. Do that consistently and most disputes die at the first representment, because the cardholder's claim of nothing arrived now contradicts a dated, located, verifiable photo of their own doorstep.

For customers: the package is marked delivered but nothing arrived

Before filing a dispute, work the short checklist. Check around the property and with neighbors or a building concierge, because drivers often leave packages out of sight. Ask the carrier for the proof of delivery, including the delivery photo and GPS scan if they have one; a photo of someone else's doorstep is itself evidence in your favor. Then contact the merchant in writing and give them a chance to reship or refund, which is faster than a dispute and leaves a paper trail.

If that fails, open the dispute with your bank and attach what you gathered: the delivered status, the mismatched photo, your messages to the merchant. Timing matters: card network rules typically give you up to around 120 days from the expected delivery date to dispute, but your bank's own deadlines prevail, so do not sit on it. Be accurate in what you claim, because filing a dispute for goods you actually received is friendly fraud, and merchants increasingly hold delivery evidence strong enough to prove it.

Which photos, at which moment

The same table serves a parcel at a doorstep, a pallet at a dock and a finished repair at a customer site. What changes is only the subject; what makes the photo weak never changes.

MomentWhat to photographWhat makes the photo contestable
At handover or drop-offThe package or goods at the delivery point, with the door number, nameplate or site reference in frameA parcel on an anonymous mat could be any address; nothing links the photo to this order
On completion of field workThe finished work next to an identifier: meter serial, equipment tag, order number on a slipAn after photo with no reference proves work was done somewhere, not at this customer's site
When the customer is presentHandover with acknowledgement: signature, or the customer's own confirmation messageA verbal okay leaves nothing for the bank; months later it is one word against another
When a dispute arrivesNothing new to shoot: export the original record with its date and address intactA photo reconstructed or edited after the fact is worse than none if the alteration shows

Sealing the delivery photo instead of defending it

Every weakness above is the same one: an ordinary photo does not prove its date, its place, or that it has not been touched. Danaya seals the photo at the moment it is taken. The driver or technician opens a capture link, the photo is shot live in the browser camera, nothing can come from the gallery, and the file is sealed with a cryptographic fingerprint, the GPS position and a server timestamp. The result is one verifiable report per order or per job in your dashboard, checkable by anyone on a public page, including the bank analyst reading your representment.

Delivery and field operations run at volume, which is why this is also an API use case: create a capture link per order from your own system and collect the sealed report back automatically. The honest limits: a sealed photo makes your delivery evidence verifiable, it does not guarantee the chargeback outcome, which stays with the card network rules and the bank.

FAQ

One sealed report per delivery or job

Send a capture link, or create one per order via the API: the photo is taken live at the doorstep or on site, sealed with a fingerprint, GPS position and server timestamp, and verifiable by anyone, including the bank.

Create a free proof

Keep reading